Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Savings Bank Account – Changing Colours


Last week the Reserve Bank of India deregulated the interest rate payable by commercial banks in India.  Till then all the banks were paying same interest rate on the balance held by the deposit holder in the SB account.  The interest payable on Fixed Deposits (FD) was deregulated few years ago.  During the last one year, two important changes were made by RBI as far as SB accounts are concerned.  The interest payable was earlier calculated by banks on the lowest balance standing in the credit of an account between 10th and 31st of a month.  Few months back, the RBI instructed the banks to do away with this practice and calculate interest based on daily balance.  This resulted in marginal increase in the interest received by deposit holders in the SB account.  The second major step was deregulation of interest rates on SB accounts.

With deregulation, we are about to see different banks offering different interest rates on SB accounts.  In fact, this has already started with some banks announcing revised rates with effect from 1st Nov.  From the bank’s point of view, this has large implications.  Money parked in SB account is highly volatile, unlike the amount locked up in FD.  This amount can be withdrawn by the customer anytime, and hence is not available for the bank for long/medium term lending.  This may create asset-liability mismatch.  In order to bring in some certainty in the balance available, some banks have announced a differential interest rate structure with higher rate of interest for balances above certain level (say Rs.1 lakh) in SB account.  I would also expect some banks to increase the minimum balance requirements in the SB account.  So we can look forward to innovative SB account products rolling out of banks in India to lure the customers.  However, form the customer’s point of view, this move makes only a marginal difference as the rate differences between banks is not going to be very high, and unlike other investments, people are not keen on shifting their SB account from one bank to another for the sake of additional 0.5% or 0.25% interest.  There are many other factors like the convenience, quality of service, net banking, payment services etc. that keep a customer with a bank, even if it pays few basis points less interest on SB.  After all we don’t park our money in SB account as an Investment!

6 comments:

  1. It has got many advantages and disadvantages. My worry is with regard to financial inclusion. As there is deregulation, an unhealthy competition may develop among banks. Unhealthy competition would result in increase in interest rate and the overall cost of funds. So, banks might discourage from maintaining saving bank deposits with very small amounts due to high transaction costs. Once banks increase the minimum balance maintained and increase the bank service charges for its customers, it would discourage opening of savings bank deposit accounts in rural and semi urban areas. Hence, the concept of No Frills Account would vanish and have adverse impact on Financial In(Ex)clusion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Vivek...you may be partially right. But as I was discussing with you this afternoon, many big/strong banks like SBI, HDFC Bank etc may still remain competitive with existing rates of interest or slightly high rates. After all, no bank can afford to take the rates beyond a point and no customer looking for higher rates would depend on SB account. And I am sure the RBI would insist on banks (at least the Govt. owned banks) not to deviate from achieving the objectives of financial inclusion.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Let me look at the other side of the coin now. Interest rates do not always go up. As the interest rates start coming down, I am sure these banks would quickly and vigorously reduce the rate on SB accounts. This is because, unlike in FD where the revised rate applies only to fresh deposits, in case of SB, the revised rate would apply to the entire money outstanding in SB accounts. Now let us look at a situation where the interest rates fall to very low levels and the banks do not reduce the minimum balance stipulation in SB account; here the customer is at a loss. In case of FD, he gets the option to choose the amount to be invested and the tenure. But in SB, the minimum balance requirement is permanently blocked with the bank; and he gets very low rate on the same. This is the price that a retail customer would have to pay to avail banking services.

    ReplyDelete
  4. No wonder if interest is given on Current account, atleast on the minimum balance presicribed by the bank. Who had thought we will get variety of Savings deposit accounts? Innovation in Financial Services are growing at a faster rate.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for explaning in simple terms sir..After looking at your thoughts on Vivek's concerns, I recalled some of the Cash models like Boumols's. If both the parties (depositor and bank) apply the same model , its again leads to a kind of Zero sum game.

    your thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Murali, let me appreciate your ability to bring concepts from varied areas to the discussion. But let us look at Baumol model, which assumes that cash consumption is at a uniform rate. Miller-Orr model relaxes this condition. But in both models, it is possible to convert cash to securities and back at any point of time. Now let us look at thi from the point of a bank. The cash collected as deposit is used for lending and the maturity of deposits and loans rarely match; with the maturity of loan being longer than that of the deposit. So how can a bank generate cash by liquidating its loans at short notice? This maturity mismatch is the biggest problem that banks face and the management of the same is broadly known as "Asset Liability Management"

    ReplyDelete